Skip to content

Retirement 101

What Makes a Good Financial Advisor or Financial Planner?

Nannette BeltFinancial Planning

A good financial advisor is clear about their licensing, has education and experience with situations like yours, explains how they are paid, tailors advice to you, is easy to reach, and explains things in plain language. Most of all, they help you make decisions. Investment returns are a weak yardstick, because markets drive them more than the advisor does.

I recently saw a Facebook post in a group I'm part of where the poster asked for referrals for a financial advisor. These posts happen often, and it got me thinking about what I would tell someone about what makes a good financial advisor or planner.

Here are the seven things I think are important, and one that isn't.

1. Clarity around licensing

The title "financial advisor" is so overused and underregulated that I think it's important to understand what someone means when they say they are licensed.

There are several different ways financial advice is regulated. I am a state-registered Registered Investment Adviser (RIA), registered with the state of California to provide investment advice to clients.

There are other kinds of licensing, like being state insurance licensed or licensed by FINRA to sell investments. I do not hold either of these licenses because I don't sell those products. I personally think that one way to be a good financial advisor is to reduce conflicts of interest in giving advice, and selling products in addition to advice isn't how I do that.

That is not to say people who sell products don't give good advice. I work with good people who do this work all the time. It's just important to understand who is regulated by whom, and what their incentives are.

2. Education and experience

I include these two topics together because while I think education (and certifications) can be indications of a good financial advisor, experience is very important as well. There's no substitute for someone who has worked with other clients who have similar situations to yours.

I think it's important to have designations like the CFP® (Certified Financial Planner). It requires a breadth of knowledge that can matter when providing comprehensive financial planning.

I also think specialized designations can be useful. I used to hold a specialized designation for divorce work, and another related to crypto assets. I currently hold the RICP® (Retirement Income Certified Professional) designation because of how it fits with the work I do with my clients.

But to me, experience with clients like you is most important. Client situations are always messier than the textbooks. A professional who has seen what you're going through before can offer guidance and empathy that can't be learned in a classroom.

3. Transparency of fees

I often see people say their advisor is the best because they're "free." Nobody works for free. If you think your advisor is free, it's because you don't know how you're paying for their work.

It shouldn't be a mystery how your advisor gets paid. They should be willing to explain it clearly and openly. I use a fee model where I get paid directly by my clients, and I think that is the right fit for the way I work. You can read more about what fee-only fiduciary means.

That doesn't mean other fee models are "bad." It just means it's important that you understand them and how they may affect the advice you receive.

4. Personalization of advice

Some advisors have a "system" they've developed, or a way of working with clients that they sell as the answer for every client. That's not how I work. I learn about each client and their individual circumstances, and adjust my advice accordingly.

This shows up in investment recommendations that change depending on the client. But it also shapes how I work with clients: how many meetings we have, what the cadence is, and how I deliver our work together.

5. Availability

Is your advisor available when you need them, and responsive to communication? It always surprises me when prospective clients are worried about reaching out. I strive to be very responsive. I'm available by phone, email, and text (and in person if you're local). My calendar is accessible directly, so clients don't have to go through three other people to book time with me.

This is also one reason I don't prefer working with clients on an hourly fee basis. Hourly billing may discourage clients from seeking help when they need it. I prefer to include regular communication and advice in our work together. The trade-off is that an hourly arrangement can be a better fit for someone who only wants help with one narrow question.

6. Personality and ability to explain

I often tell prospective clients that finding an advisor is like finding a therapist. You need to find one you fit with personally. Some advisors are very dry and clinical, and that works for some clients. I value the ability to bring my authentic self to my work with clients.

I also don't pretend that what I do is so complicated that clients couldn't possibly understand what I'm recommending or the work I'm doing for them. I didn't grow up in this industry, so I approach my work with a lens toward always being able to explain what I'm doing in terms every client can understand. That isn't the case with all advisors.

7. Help with decisions and reaching your goals

This might be the most important criterion. Even if an advisor has all the qualities you're looking for, at the end of the day you want help with the decisions and goals that matter to you.

Sometimes that means advising clients on exactly what to do. But often it means explaining the options and their pros and cons, and guiding you toward the decision that's best for you. I'm also there to help you balance the person you are today with the person you want to be tomorrow. I can help you evaluate the consequences of today's decisions, and understand what may be possible given where you are today.

What doesn't tell you whether an advisor is good: investment returns

I see it all the time: people saying their advisor is great because their investments are growing, or have done well over time. I always ask what they are comparing it to. Investment returns have much more to do with what the market does than with what the advisor does.

Are there basics around investing that matter? Yes. Your advisor should help you invest in a portfolio that makes sense for your goals, risk tolerance, and time horizon, and should be able to explain why they recommend the investments they do. I personally think investments should be low-cost, publicly available (not proprietary), and easy to understand.

But sometimes investments lose value. It's what the advisor does during those times that makes this work valuable to you. I help clients understand how a decline affects their plan, whether they may need to make changes, and what to do going forward. You deserve advice during the good times and the bad.

If you'd like to talk it through

If you're comparing advisors, I'm happy to answer these questions about how I work. Book an intro call and we can see whether we're a fit.

This article is for general educational purposes only and is not personalized investment, tax, or legal advice. Investing involves risk, including the potential loss of principal. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training. See the full disclaimer.

Want help applying this to your situation?

We use cookies and similar technologies to understand how our site is used and to improve your experience. Learn more